Google Ads Copy: The Most Common Mistakes with RSA and P-Max – and How to Avoid Them
Teilen
You have set up the targeting, defined the budget, and launched the campaign. And yet, very little is happening. Clicks are coming in, but no inquiries. Or the CPC is far too high.
Most of the time, it is not the budget. Not the targeting. It is the copy.
Today, Google Ads is largely a game of copy. Responsive Search Ads and Performance Max automatically combine your headlines and descriptions – and if the inputs are poor, the outputs are even worse. Garbage in, garbage out.
This article shows the most common mistakes – and what fundamentally distinguishes RSA and P-Max when it comes to copy.
RSA and P-Max – two formats, two logics
Before we get to the mistakes: a brief understanding of the differences is crucial, because they have direct consequences for the copy.
Responsive Search Ads (RSA) appear in Google Search. The user has actively searched for something – they have an intention. Your headlines and descriptions must respond to this intention. The keyword that someone entered must be reflected in the ad – otherwise, no one will click.
Performance Max (P-Max) serves all Google channels simultaneously: Search, Display, YouTube, Gmail, Discover, Maps. The user may not have actively searched at all – they are scrolling through YouTube or reading an article. The ad must grab attention and pique interest, not just answer a search query.
That sounds like a minor difference. But it is a fundamental one. RSA copy used for P-Max usually performs poorly – and vice versa.
The most common mistakes with RSA
Headlines that do not work independently
Google combines your headlines freely. It shows up to three headlines at a time – but not always the same three, and not always in the same order. What you write must make sense in every combination and in every order.
The classic mistake: headlines that build on each other.
"Now" as the first headline, "book" as the second, "and save 20%" as the third. Individually, none of the three make sense. Together, maybe – but only if Google shows them in exactly that order. Which is rarely the case.
Every headline must stand on its own. "Save 20% now" is a standalone headline. "Now" alone is not.
Too few variations
The minimum is 3 headlines and 2 descriptions. That is too few. Google needs variations to optimize – if you only provide the minimum, you give the algorithm no room to work.
Recommendation: At least 8–10 headlines, 3–4 descriptions. The maximum allowed is 15 headlines and 4 descriptions. The more meaningful variations, the more combinations Google can test – and the faster the system finds what works.
All headlines say the same thing
Ten headlines that all vary "Cheap", "Fast", and "Reliable" are not ten different headlines. They are the same statement ten times.
Different headlines should cover different aspects: one about the USP, one about the price, one about the target audience, one about the problem being solved, one with a concrete offer, one with social proof. The more diverse the topics, the more Google learns which message resonates with which user.
Keyword stuffing
Keywords in headlines are important – but an ad that consists only of keywords is not readable. "Buy cheap shoes online in Zurich" is not copy, it is a keyword list.
Google evaluates relevance, but also quality. A well-readable headline that naturally includes the keyword performs better than one where it is forced in.
Descriptions repeat the headlines
Descriptions are not there to say again what the headline has already said. They are there to complement. To provide details. To explain the next step.
Headline: "Shoes directly from the manufacturer"
Bad description: "Buy shoes directly from the manufacturer online."
Good description: Over 200 models. Free delivery from CHF 80. 30-day returns."
No CTA
Many ads say what they offer – but not what the user should do. "Book a free initial consultation", "Request a quote now", "Order today" – a clear call-to-action in at least one description measurably increases the click-through rate.
The most common mistakes with P-Max
Simply copying RSA copy
This is the most common mistake of all. P-Max does not only appear in search. A headline that answers a search query ("Buy shoes in Zurich") does not work as a display ad on a news website – the user was not even searching for shoes.
P-Max copy must work more broadly. It must grab attention without the context of a search query. Concrete benefit, clear message, direct appeal.
Too generic long headlines
P-Max has a format that RSA does not know: long headlines with up to 90 characters. These appear prominently on Display and YouTube. Many write generic sentences there like "We are the best choice for your marketing".
90 characters is space for a real message. Use it. "We implemented the first programmatic campaigns in Switzerland in 2009 – and know what works today." That is a long headline that builds trust.
Business name is missing or incorrect
P-Max has its own field for the business name – max. 25 characters. Many forget it, leave it blank, or enter the URL. The business name appears in the ad and is a branding element. It should be named after your brand.
Copy without a connection to the images
In P-Max, Google automatically combines copy and images. If the copy talks about "innovation and technology" and the images show nature photos, a content contradiction arises. Copy and images should describe the same world.
No variation in tone
With RSA, the tone is relatively clear – someone is actively searching, you respond directly. With P-Max, the ad reaches people at different moments. A variation in tone – factual, emotional, concrete, curious – gives Google more room to show the right message at the right moment.
What RSA and P-Max have in common – and why different copy is still needed
Both formats are based on the same principle: You provide assets, Google combines and optimizes. Both need many variations. Both benefit from clear, standalone copy.
But the requirements for the copy itself are different:
| RSA | P-Max | |
|---|---|---|
| Context | Active search | All channels, no search context |
| Tone | Direct, keyword-relevant | Broader, attention-grabbing |
| Headlines short | 30 characters, min. 3, max. 15 | 30 characters, min. 3, max. 15 |
| Headlines long | – | 90 characters, min. 1, max. 5 |
| Descriptions | 90 characters, min. 2, max. 4 | 90 characters, min. 3, max. 5 |
| Most important rule | Standalone in every combination | Works without search context |
What makes good Google Ads copy – regardless of format
Concrete instead of generic. "Digital solutions for your business" says nothing. "Google Ads campaigns for SMEs in Switzerland" says something.
Benefits instead of features. "25 years of experience" is a feature. "Campaigns that perform – because we have known what works since 2009" is a benefit.
One message per headline. Not everything at once. Every headline has a job.
Numbers work. "Over 100 customers", "since 2009", "30-minute initial consultation" – concrete numbers build trust and stand out from generic copy.
Testing is mandatory. No copy is perfect from the start. Google shows you in the asset report which headlines and descriptions perform "Good", "Average", or "Low". Replace weak assets, keep strong ones – that is the process.
Before you start: structure helps
The biggest problem with writing Google Ads copy is not a lack of talent – it is a lack of structure. Many just start and type randomly. The result is headlines that resemble each other, descriptions that repeat what the headline already says, and an asset set that gives Google no room to work.
A structured collection – with clear fields, character counters, and an overview of what is still missing – makes the difference. Not only for the quality of the copy, but also for the collaboration between client and agency.
If you want to collect your Google Ads copy in a structured way and submit it directly – we have built a tool for that. Briefing and copy in one step, with a live character counter for RSA and P-Max.
Questions about your campaigns? We are happy to take a look – 30 minutes, free, no pitch.